Brown sugar is one of the most versatile baking ingredients out there. From cookies to cakes, it adds a delicious sweetness that any other ingredient can’t replicate. But sometimes, you need a brown sugar substitute in your recipes – and that’s where these 12 brown sugar substitutes come in! Read on for all the details about why these are the best brown sugar substitutes.

Jump to:
- What is Brown Sugar?
- Uses for Brown Sugar
- List of 12 Best Brown Sugar Substitutes
- 1. DIY Brown Sugar
- 2. Coconut sugar
- 3. Date sugar
- 4. Demerara sugar
- 5. Sucanat (unrefined cane sugar)
- 6. Turbinado sugar
- 7. Muscovado sugar
- 8. Palm Sugar
- 9. Jaggery
- 10. Honey, Agave nectar, or Maple syrup
- 11. Blackstrap molasses
- 12. Brown Rice Syrup or Barley
- People Also Ask [FAQs]
- Wrap Up: Brown Sugar Substitute
- 🍽️ Recipe
What is Brown Sugar?
Brown sugar is made from white sugar that has been combined with molasses. It comes in both light and dark varieties; the darker the sugar, the more intense the flavor.
Light brown sugar has a mild molasses flavor and a pale golden color, while dark brown sugar has an intense molasses flavor and a deep caramel color.
Both types are perfect for baking as they add moisture and can help enhance flavors in cakes, cookies, pies, and muffins—you name it!
Uses for Brown Sugar
Brown sugars have many uses beyond baking! They add sweetness to oatmeal or yogurt bowls, give pancakes a boost of flavor, or can even be sprinkled on top of French toast before serving.
You can also use them to sweeten your morning coffee or tea by adding it directly into your mug or using it as an alternative sweetener for recipes like lattes or chai teas.
And because it adds such great moisture content to baked goods, you can use it for anything from banana bread to cookies to scones!
List of 12 Best Brown Sugar Substitutes
Running out of brown sugar can be a real bummer when you’re in the middle of baking something delicious. Don’t worry though—there’s an easy solution!

1. DIY Brown Sugar
Make your own brown sugar by combining white granulated sugar with molasses to make your own homemade version of brown sugar.
- To make light brown sugar, mix 1 cup (200g) of white granulated sugar with 1 tablespoon (15 ml) of molasses.
- To make dark brown sugar mix 1 cup (200g) of white granulated sugar with 2 tablespoons (30ml)of molasses.
2. Coconut sugar
Coconut sugar is made by boiling down the sap extracted from the flower buds of coconut palms. The boiled-down liquid slowly crystallizes into granules that resemble light brown sugar.
It has an earthy flavor and a subtle hint of molasses. It’s perfect for baking cakes, cookies, muffins, and other desserts. For best results, use it in combination with honey or maple syrup when replacing brown sugar in recipes.

3. Date sugar
Date sugar is dried dates that have been ground into a fine powder. It has a rich caramel flavor that pairs well with oatmeal cookies and banana bread.
Date sugar can be used as an exact replacement for brown sugar in most recipes without any alterations needed. Its coarse texture makes it difficult to dissolve in cold beverages, so it’s best used as an additive to baked goods instead of cold drinks like smoothies or shakes.

4. Demerara sugar
Demerara Sugar is made from evaporated cane juice that has been lightly filtered and pressed into crystals before being dried out completely.
It’s got large grains with golden-brown color and a mild molasses flavor that adds just the right amount of sweetness to oatmeal or muesli bowls. Demerara works especially well when sprinkled on top of cakes as decoration since its crunchy texture contrasts the softness of cakes and other desserts!
5. Sucanat (unrefined cane sugar)
Sucanat is created by pressing freshly harvested cane juice until it forms large granules with golden-brown coloration and a full-bodied flavor profile.
Since this type of sugar isn’t refined like regular white sugars are, its taste remains much closer to the natural flavor of raw cane juice than other types of sweeteners do—making it ideal for baking pies or cobblers where you want more pronounced flavors than what conventional white sugars offer!

6. Turbinado sugar
Turbinado is a type of raw cane sugar from freshly harvested cane plants. It is minimally processed and lightly refined, giving it a unique flavor and texture you won’t get from regular granulated sugars.
It is slightly coarser than standard white sugars and has a light golden hue with hints of molasses flavor. Turbinado is an excellent substitute for brown sugar because of its similar texture and sweet flavor. When using it as a substitute for brown sugar, use twice or one and a half times as much turbinado as you would normally use brown sugar to get the same level of sweetness.

7. Muscovado sugar
Muscovado is another type of raw cane sugar that has been minimally processed but has more molasses than turbinado or other types of raw cane sugars.
The result is a deep golden color with intense molasses flavors, making this an excellent choice for baking with strong flavor profiles like chocolate or gingerbread.
It also has some interesting health benefits since it contains minerals like potassium and magnesium, which are beneficial for general health maintenance.
To replace brown sugar with muscovado sugar, use the same amount when substituting muscovado for granulated white sugar or half the amount when using it as a dark brown sugar substitute

8. Palm Sugar
Palm sugar comes from the sap of certain palm trees species such as Toddy palms or Palmyra palms in India and Southeast Asia. This sap is boiled until it crystallizes into small grains which are then dried into what we know as palm sugar granules (or flakes).
Palm sugars have a unique flavor profile with caramel notes combined with mild floral notes which makes them perfect substitutes for light or dark brown sugars in baking recipes like cakes or breads where they can really shine through!
To substitute palm sugars in place of regular white sugars, use twice as much while to substitute them in place of light/dark brown sugars use half as much (as per recommendations above).

9. Jaggery
Jaggery is another type of unrefined cane sugar made from boiling down sap from various species of palm trees until crystals form (similar to palm sugar).
The difference between jaggery and other types of unrefined cane sugars lies in its production process – jaggery does not require any additional refining steps so its flavor is more robust than other types of unrefined cane sugars due to its higher content of minerals like iron, calcium, and zinc along with vitamins B1 & B2 present naturally in its raw form!
Jaggery works well as an alternative to both light/dark brown sugars when used at half the amount recommended by recipe instructions (again according to instructions above).

10. Honey, Agave nectar, or Maple syrup
These three sweeteners are all great alternatives to use in place of brown sugar. All three are naturally occurring sugars, so they add flavor as well as sweetness.
They also lend moisture to baked goods like cakes, cookies, and muffins. When substituting these for brown sugar in recipes, reduce the other liquid ingredients by ¼ cup for every 1 cup of honey/agave/maple syrup.
11. Blackstrap molasses
This dark syrup is made during the process of refining sugarcane into table sugar and adds a unique depth of flavor to recipes. Blackstrap molasses adds color and richness, making desserts like gingerbread stand out from the rest.
It’s best used in small amounts when substituted for brown sugar since it has such a strong flavor and can easily overpower other ingredients if not used carefully.
To substitute blackstrap molasses for brown sugar in recipes, replace each 1 cup of light or dark brown sugar with ¾ cup blackstrap molasses and reduce the liquid ingredients by 3 tablespoons per ¾ cup of blackstrap molasses used.
12. Brown Rice Syrup or Barley
Both of these products have complex flavors that pair perfectly with fruit-based recipes like streusels, pies, crumbles, cobblers, and jams.
Brown rice syrup has more nutritional value than many other sweeteners because it contains minerals like manganese and zinc while barley syrup adds a mild maltiness to desserts like blondies and oatmeal bars.
To substitute either one for brown sugar in recipes, replace each 1 cup of light or dark brown sugar with 1¼ cups barley or rice syrup and reduce other liquids by 3 tablespoons per 1¼ cups barley/rice syrup used.

People Also Ask [FAQs]
To ensure the highest quality, brown sugar should be stored in a cool, moist environment in a rustproof container with a tight-fitting lid or re-sealable, moisture-proof plastic bag and consumed within six months of purchase and opening.
Brown sugar does not expire, but it should be stored properly to ensure its longevity. If there is bug contamination, bad smells, or mold growing on the brown sugar, it should not be consumed.
Brown sugar is not necessarily healthier than white sugar, as they are nutritionally similar.
Wrap Up: Brown Sugar Substitute
- When it comes to substituting brown sugar in recipes, there are many options available.
- Whether you choose white sugars, jaggery, honey or agave nectar, maple syrup blackstrap molasses, or barley and rice syrups, each can uniquely flavor your dishes.
- However, make sure that when using any of these alternatives for brown sugar, the liquid ingredients should be reduced accordingly per the instructions above.
- Additionally, store brown sugar properly if looking to preserve its quality over time, and avoid consuming it if bug contamination is present on the product surface.
- Finally, remember that nutritionally speaking both white and brown sugars have similar properties so neither one provides health benefits over the other.
🍽️ Recipe
How to Make Brown Sugar
Ingredients
Light Brown Sugar:
- 1 cup white granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon molasses
Dark Brown Sugar:
- 1 cup white granulated sugar
- 2 tablespoons molasses
Instructions
- Starting off, mix the two ingredients together in a bowl.
- Once they're thoroughly combined, transfer them to an air-tight container to keep it fresh.
Notes
- If you like your brown sugars on the drier side, I recommend cutting down the amount of molasses by a teaspoon or so when making both light and dark-colored sugars for future use!
- For a more robust flavor, consider adding a pinch of cinnamon or nutmeg to the brown sugar blend. This will add an extra layer of depth and complexity to your homemade brown sugar.
- Additionally, try using demerara or turbinado sugar instead of white granulated sugar for a slightly different taste.
Leave a Comment